Skip the Supermarket and Buy Your Thanksgiving Pie from a Local Bakery

Are you ready to indulge in some mouthwatering pies for Thanksgiving? If you live in south jersey, you have plenty of options to choose from. We have found some of the best bakeries that offer amazing pies for the holiday season in South Jersey. Whether you are a fan of traditional pies like apple, pumpkin, or pecan, or you want to try something new like salted caramel apple or bourbon chocolate walnut, you will not be disappointed by these bakeries. Here are some of the most popular and highly rated places to satisfy your pie cravings this Thanksgiving!

McMillan’s Bakery

Do you love pie as much as we do? McMillan’s was listed as one of the South Jersey bakeries that will satisfy your pie craving! Our family owned and operated bakery is the pure essence of tradition. Established in 1939 and  run by the original family till today, in the fourth generation the traditional artisan habits continue to be passed along.

Pied Out Bakeshop

This cozy bakery and café specializes in pies of all kinds, from sweet to savory. All breakfast items are available as well as baked goods. If you have not ordered your thanksgiving pies yet here’s your last reminder!

Tis So Sweet Bakery

Hosting thanksgiving dinner this year 🦃 and want a delicious dessert to add to your table? Order a tray of our famous homemade cobblers or crisp. Our bakers start work before the sun rises each day to ensure that every batch is as fresh as possible before it gets to you. 

Sweetsboro Pastry Shoppe

Thanksgiving is approaching quickly. Get your dessert order in soon! Don’t get left out. Reminder: our phones are very busy with customers placing orders. If you can not get through, try later in the day. Or, if possible, come in! We are awesome and would love to see your faces!

JB Bakery

Burlington County locals regard JB Bakery as “their” bakery. Family owned and operated since 1952, it’s more than a bakery — it’s a vital part of the community. Whether they’re celebrating birthdays, weddings, holidays, or simply dessert, people share a connection with JB. Drop in for a visit — chances are, “their” bakery will become “your” bakery as well!

Cacia’s Bakery

Specializing in: Italian bread/rolls, Award winning pizza (red cheese, white, tomato, cheese steak, vegetable, pizzaz ), Stromboli(pepperoni, vegetable, philly cheese steak, roast pork, broccoli rabe & sharp provolone).  We also offer many homemade pies, cakes and cannoli to cater to your sweet tooth. Our South Jersey locations offer full service Deli items with over 30 specialty hoagies!

Anita’s Pies

We are proud to be from this area, living and working on supporting local farmers, businesses, and helping Hammonton become an arts and entertainment destination for folks in Philadelphia and the Atlantic City areas.

Deluxe Italian Bakery Inc

Welcome to Deluxe Italian Bakery! For over a half century, Deluxe Italian Bakery has taken pride in bringing our customers fresh, natural, great tasting Italian breads, rolls and pastries.In everything we bake, we take pride and carry the tradition of quality and integrity, passed down from our grandfather, who founded the bakery in 1949.